Accessibility in E-Commerce: Why True Inclusion Goes Beyond BFSG Compliance

In our increasingly connected society, digital accessibility is gaining ever-greater importance. It is the key to inclusion of all people in the digital age, enabling everyone—regardless of physical or cognitive limitations—to participate equally in digital life. According to statistics from IT-Daily, 10.4 million people with disabilities live in Germany, and approximately 1 billion worldwide. These impressive numbers underscore the urgency of making digital offerings accessible to everyone.

Digital accessibility means that websites, apps, and digital documents are designed so that they can be used by everyone—regardless of any limitations. This encompasses not only people with obvious disabilities but also older individuals or people with temporary impairments. Implementing accessibility in the digital space is not only an ethical obligation but also a commercial opportunity, as it expands the user base and improves overall usability.

In this context, Artificial Intelligence (AI) plays an increasingly important role. It offers innovative solutions to make digital content more accessible and break down barriers. From automatic image descriptions to intelligent text-to-speech functions—AI is revolutionizing how we implement and experience digital accessibility. But here's the critical insight that most businesses miss: true accessibility goes far beyond technical compliance.

What Does Digital Accessibility Mean Today?

Digital accessibility is a comprehensive concept aimed at making digital content and technologies accessible and usable for all people, regardless of their physical or cognitive abilities. According to the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), the international standard for accessible web design, digital accessibility is based on four fundamental principles:

1. Perceivability: Information and user interfaces must be presented in ways that all users can perceive. This includes text alternatives for images, subtitles for videos, or the ability to adjust contrasts.
2. Operability: All functions of a website or app must be operable with various input methods—not just with a mouse, but also with keyboard or voice control.
3. Understandability: Information and operation of the user interface must be understandable for all users. This encompasses clear and simple language as well as consistent navigation.
4. Robustness: Content must be robust enough to be reliably interpreted by a wide variety of user agents, including assistive technologies.

Digital accessibility extends far beyond the needs of people with disabilities. It improves the user experience for everyone by increasing the accessibility and usability of digital offerings. An accessible design can help older people who may have difficulty with small text, or people in noisy environments who rely on subtitles.

Implementing digital accessibility requires a holistic approach that considers technical, design, and content aspects. It's about designing digital products inclusively from the ground up, rather than adding accessibility as an afterthought. This leads not only to better outcomes for people with disabilities but often to innovative solutions that benefit all users.

The BFSG Law: What Applies from June 2025

The legal framework for digital accessibility has gained significant importance in recent years. The Accessibility Strengthening Act (BFSG) was passed in Germany in July 2021 to implement the European Accessibility Act. This law marks a milestone in efforts to make digital offerings accessible to all people.

The BFSG defines accessibility requirements for products and services that are made available to consumers after June 28, 2025. This encompasses a broad spectrum of digital offerings, including online commerce, hardware, software, transportation services, and banking services. The regulations apply to manufacturers, retailers, importers, and service providers, with exceptions for very small businesses.

Beyond the BFSG, international standards also play an important role. The WCAG provides concrete guidelines and testable success criteria at three levels (A, AA, AAA), with EU standards establishing Levels A and AA as binding criteria. The legal requirements present companies and organizations with new challenges but also offer opportunities for a more inclusive digital world.

Why WCAG Standards Are Only the Beginning

Here's where most businesses—and most content about accessibility—stop: they focus entirely on meeting WCAG 2.1 Level AA as the legal baseline. But a technically compliant site can still be incredibly frustrating to use. This is the critical distinction between passive compliance and active inclusion.

Consider this scenario: A blind user wants to purchase a laptop from an online shop. The website is technically WCAG-compliant—all images have alt-text, the HTML structure is correct, and keyboard navigation works. But the user faces 500 products across dozens of categories. Using a screen reader to navigate filter menus for processor type, RAM, screen size, price range, and brand becomes an exhausting, time-consuming ordeal.

The website is compliant. But is it truly accessible in any meaningful sense? The user can theoretically access all the information, but the practical experience is so painful that they'll likely abandon the purchase entirely.

Active vs. Passive Accessibility: The Critical Difference

The accessibility industry has focused almost entirely on what we might call passive accessibility: ensuring that content can be perceived and that interfaces can be operated. Alt-texts, keyboard navigation, sufficient contrast—these are essential foundations. But they represent a defensive approach: removing barriers so users can access content.

Active accessibility goes further. It means proactively guiding users to their goals, rather than simply not blocking their path. Instead of making a user navigate through a complex filter system with assistive technology, active accessibility provides an intelligent interface that understands what the user needs and guides them directly there.

This is where AI Product Consultation represents a paradigm shift. Rather than expecting users with disabilities to master complex navigation systems—even accessible ones—AI consultation creates a conversational interface that works the same way for everyone. A visually impaired user can simply say or type: 'I need a washing machine for a small family, under €500, with good energy efficiency.' The AI does the navigation work, not the user.

The Role of AI in Digital Inclusion

Artificial Intelligence is revolutionizing the landscape of digital accessibility and opening new possibilities for inclusive access to the digital world. As a powerful technology, AI offers innovative solutions for many of the challenges people with disabilities face in the digital space.

A major advantage of AI lies in its ability to recognize and process complex patterns. This enables digital content to be adapted and transformed in real-time to make it accessible for various user groups. For example, AI can convert text to speech, describe images, or translate complex information into simpler formats.

The adaptability of AI systems is another decisive factor. Artificial Intelligence like GPT-5 is expected to have improved multimodal capabilities such as speech and image processing. This means AI systems can process different types of inputs and respond accordingly, making them particularly valuable for supporting people with different disabilities.

Generative AI vs. Simple Chatbots: A Crucial Difference

It's essential to distinguish between old FAQ bots and modern Product Consultation AI. Traditional chatbots follow rigid scripts and keyword matching—they frustrate users when questions don't match predefined patterns. For users with cognitive impairments or those who express themselves differently, these limitations become serious barriers.

Modern AI employees can understand natural language, process context, and provide personalized recommendations. They can understand that 'something for my mom's birthday' in a jewelry store context means gift recommendations, even without explicit keywords. This contextual understanding is crucial for users with cognitive or physical limitations who may not express needs in standardized ways.

Furthermore, AI can help identify and eliminate barriers that might not be obvious to human developers. By analyzing large amounts of data and usage patterns, AI can uncover problems and generate solution proposals that continuously improve the accessibility of digital offerings.

Case Study: How AI Consultation Breaks Down Barriers

Let's examine a concrete scenario that illustrates the power of AI-driven accessibility. Consider Maria, a user with motor impairment who struggles with fine motor control. Traditional e-commerce interfaces present significant challenges: small filter checkboxes, dropdown menus requiring precise mouse movements, and complex multi-step processes.

On a standard accessible website, Maria can technically navigate—tab key works, focus indicators are visible. But each filter selection requires precise input, and comparing products means navigating back and forth repeatedly. A task that takes an able-bodied user 5 minutes might take Maria 25 minutes of exhausting effort.

Now imagine the same shop with AI Product Consultation. Maria types (or uses voice input): 'I need a washing machine for a small family, under 500 euros, and it needs to be quiet because I work from home.' The AI immediately understands multiple requirements—capacity, budget, noise level—and presents three relevant options with clear comparisons.

Maria asks: 'Which one is easiest to load?' The AI explains the different door designs and recommends the model with the widest opening. Maria makes her purchase in under 5 minutes, without a single complex navigation interaction.

AI-Powered Solutions for Enhanced Accessibility

AI offers a multitude of applications that can significantly improve digital accessibility. Here are some of the most important areas where AI is already making a major impact:

Automatic Image Descriptions and Alt-Texts

AI systems can automatically generate detailed and contextually relevant descriptions for images. This technology is particularly valuable for blind and visually impaired users who rely on screen readers. The AI analyzes image content and creates meaningful alt-texts that convey the essential elements and meaning of the image. This enables users to understand visual content without seeing it.

AI-Based Captioning and Transcription

Advanced AI algorithms can convert speech to text in real-time while also capturing nuances like tone and emotion. This technology finds application in automatic captioning systems for videos and live streams, significantly improving access for deaf and hard-of-hearing people. An example is the Live Transcribe app, which offers free real-time speech-to-text transcription for Android devices.

Speech Recognition and Output

AI-powered speech recognition systems enable users to control digital devices and applications solely through voice commands. This is particularly useful for people with limited mobility or visual impairments. At the same time, AI systems can convert written text into natural-sounding speech, improving the accessibility of written content for blind users or people with reading difficulties.

Content Adaptation to Individual Needs

AI systems can dynamically adapt content to the specific needs and preferences of individual users. This can include simplifying texts for people with cognitive impairments, adjusting color contrasts for users with visual impairments, or optimizing navigation elements for people with motor limitations. AI employees can understand and process natural language and provide personalized recommendations, further improving the user experience.

A concrete example of AI use in digital accessibility is the Seeing AI app. This free application uses AI to describe the world for blind and visually impaired users. It can read text aloud, identify products, and even interpret facial expressions.

WhatsApp bots can conduct more natural and context-related conversations, which can also be beneficial for accessibility. They can function as personal assistants available around the clock, supporting people with disabilities in navigating digital services.

AI-Powered Accessibility Testing and Optimization

Artificial Intelligence is revolutionizing not only the user experience for people with disabilities but also how we test and optimize digital offerings for accessibility. AI-powered tools enable more efficient and comprehensive analysis of websites and digital applications, significantly accelerating and improving the accessibility testing process.

A significant advantage of AI-based testing tools is their ability to process large amounts of data in the shortest time. They can scan entire websites and identify potential barriers that could be problematic for people with various disabilities. These tools can recognize missing alt-texts for images, insufficient color contrasts, or inaccessible forms.

However, it's important to emphasize that AI tools cannot completely replace human expertise. According to IT-Daily, automated tests capture only about 30% of accessibility problems. Manual tests by people with disabilities therefore remain crucial for comprehensive accessibility testing. AI tools should be viewed as complementary resources that support human experts in their work.

An innovative approach to raising awareness about digital accessibility was developed by the digital agency denkwerk. Instead of launching another technical testing tool, they chose an empathetic approach. With the help of Generative AI, the personas Claudia and Cosmo were created, who test any entered website on behalf of people with visual or motor impairments. The result is not a technical error report but an empathy report from the perspective of real people who use the pages and experience frustration when they encounter problems.

AI-powered optimization tools go one step further. They can not only identify problems but also generate solution proposals. These tools can suggest alternative texts for images, recommend color schemes for better contrast, or make suggestions for improving navigation structure. These AI-generated proposals can serve as starting points for developers and designers to make their digital offerings more accessible.

Challenges in Implementing Digital Accessibility

Despite legal requirements and growing awareness of the importance of digital accessibility, many companies and organizations face significant challenges in implementation. A test by Aktion Mensch found that only 20% of the examined online shops could be classified as accessible. This sobering figure illustrates the great need for action in this area.

One of the main difficulties lies in technical implementation. Many websites and digital offerings were not designed to be accessible from the ground up, making subsequent adaptation complex and costly. Particularly challenging is ensuring complete keyboard operability—an essential criterion for accessibility that is often not met.

Another obstacle is the often lacking awareness and expertise in companies. The complexity of the topic and the multitude of aspects to consider overwhelm many developers and designers. Additionally, there is often a lack of resources and budget for comprehensive accessibility measures, especially in smaller companies.

The dynamics of the digital world present an additional challenge. Constantly new technologies and trends require continuous adaptation and review of accessibility. Automated tests alone are not sufficient. According to a study cited in IT-Daily, automated tests capture only about 30% of accessibility problems. Manual tests by people with disabilities are therefore essential, which in turn requires time and resources.

Future Accessibility Checklist for Your Digital Offering

Is your e-commerce business truly ready for the accessibility future? Use this comprehensive checklist to evaluate your current status and identify gaps:

Technical Audit (WCAG Compliance)

• All images have meaningful alt-text descriptions
• Color contrast ratios meet WCAG AA standards (4.5:1 for normal text)
• Full keyboard navigation is possible for all functions
• Form fields have proper labels and error messages
• Video content includes captions and transcripts
• Page structure uses semantic HTML and proper heading hierarchy

BFSG Compliance Check

• Your business falls under BFSG scope (B2C digital services or e-commerce)
• Accessibility statement is published and current
• Processes exist for receiving and addressing accessibility feedback
• Staff training on accessibility requirements is documented
• Third-party components and plugins have been evaluated for accessibility

Consultation Check: The Active Accessibility Layer

• Users can find products without relying on complex filter navigation
• Alternative input methods (voice, conversation) are available
• Product discovery works effectively for users with various disabilities
• The path from need to purchase requires minimal cognitive load
• AI consultation understands context and provides personalized guidance

Ethical Considerations and Limits of AI in Accessibility

While AI undoubtedly offers enormous potential for improving digital accessibility, it's important to also consider the ethical implications and possible limits of this technology. The use of AI in this sensitive area raises important questions that must be carefully weighed.

A central aspect is data privacy. AI systems often require large amounts of user data to function effectively. When processing data from people with disabilities, who are considered particularly vulnerable, special caution is required. It must be ensured that this data is stored securely, treated confidentially, and not misused for other purposes.

Another important point is the possible bias of AI systems. If the training data on which the AI is based is not diverse enough or reflects existing societal prejudices, this could lead to discriminatory results. It is therefore crucial that the development of AI systems for digital accessibility pays attention to the broadest and most representative data base possible.

The Federal Agency for Civic Education points to further concerns, particularly in education. These include the possible isolation of students through overly individualized AI-supported learning programs. It's important to find a balance between individualized learning and the social aspect of group instruction.

The danger of over-reliance on AI systems should also not be underestimated. While AI employees and assistive technologies can certainly be helpful, they must not lead to neglecting the development of real skills and independence.

Finally, there are also limits to what AI can achieve in terms of accessibility. Despite all advances, AI cannot fully replace human understanding of the individual needs and experiences of people with disabilities. The involvement of people with disabilities in the development process of digital offerings remains essential.

Despite these challenges, the opportunities that AI offers for digital accessibility far outweigh the risks. With responsible and ethically reflective use, AI can make a significant contribution to a more inclusive digital world. It is our responsibility to design and deploy this technology in ways that truly benefit all people.

Future Perspectives: How AI Will Further Revolutionize Accessibility

The future of digital accessibility is marked by artificial intelligence. AI technologies are developing rapidly and promise to fundamentally improve access to the digital world for people with disabilities. According to experts, we are only at the beginning of a revolution that has the potential to raise inclusivity in the digital space to a new level.

Multimodal AI Systems

A promising trend is multimodal AI systems like GPT-5, which can simultaneously process text, speech, and images. This technology could transform the way people with different disabilities interact with digital content. For example, blind users could grasp complex visual content through detailed audio descriptions, while deaf users benefit from precise captioning and sign language translations.

Personalized AI Assistants

AI employees and digital assistants will become even more intelligent and adaptable in the future. They will be able to understand the individual needs and preferences of each user and adapt the digital environment accordingly. This could mean that websites and apps automatically adapt to the requirements of the respective user, whether through changing font size, contrast, or navigation method.

Advances in Speech Technology

The continued development of speech technologies will revolutionize communication for people with speech or hearing disabilities. WhatsApp bots and other AI-controlled communication tools will be able to conduct more natural and context-related conversations. This could lead to seamless integration of voice control into all aspects of digital life, from social media use to online banking.

AI-Powered Real-Time Translation and Adaptation

Future AI systems could translate not only between languages in real-time but also between different forms of communication. Imagine a system that automatically translates spoken language into sign language, or converts written text into tactile outputs for people with visual impairments. This would drastically reduce barriers in digital communication.

Neural Interfaces and Assistive Technologies

In the long term, advances in neurotechnology combined with AI could lead to revolutionary assistive technologies. Direct interfaces between brain and computer could enable people with severe physical disabilities to control digital devices through thoughts alone. Although this technology is still in its infancy, it shows the enormous potential of AI to extend the boundaries of digital accessibility.

Accessibility as Competitive Advantage

The future of digital accessibility through AI promises a world where technological barriers belong to the past. With continued development and responsible use of these technologies, we can create a truly inclusive digital society where every person, regardless of their abilities, can participate equally.

But here's the business case that too many companies overlook: accessibility is not just ethical—it's profitable. The 10.4 million people with disabilities in Germany alone represent enormous purchasing power. Add temporary impairments, aging populations, and situational disabilities (bright sunlight, loud environments, occupied hands), and you're talking about serving the majority of your potential customers better.

Companies that implement AI Product Consultation don't just check a compliance box—they create genuinely superior shopping experiences. They reduce cart abandonment, increase customer satisfaction, and build brand loyalty among communities that remember which businesses served them well.

Frequently Asked Questions